Five Elves of Unquestionable Likeability

By Anne Perry

Posted on March 10, 2016 in Books, Film, Fun Stuff with tags Daniel Polansky, Those Above, Those Below

Those Below, the second half of Daniel Polansky’s incredible epic duology, The Empty Throne, publishes today! Given that Those Above and Those Below tell a story about, essentially, the decline and fall of the elvish empire, we figured there was no better way to celebrate than to highlight five elves we’re personally very fond of. Well, four elves we’re fond of and one elf we have some questions about.

Because we love you, we have hand-illustrated this post. Lucky you!

The Tolkien Elf: Thranduil

thranduilObviously no list of elves could be complete without including an elf of Middle Earth. I could write about Legolas, the hottest of the elves, or Elrond, the most useful of the elves. Or Galadriel, the secret true badass of the elves. But do any of them ride a war-moose? DO THEY? No. Therefore the best elf in all of Middle Earth is Thranduil, father of Legolas, rider of a GIGANTIC FREAKING MOOSE WTF. He has a flair for the dramatic, weird scars, a bad attitude and the most ridiculous crown. And an even more ridiculous throne. Also: moose. (I am obviously talking about the movie version of Thranduil.) (You might try to point out here that he rides an elk in the films, not a moose, but you are wrong. MOOSE.)


The videogame elf: Link

legend of zeldaOkay, in all honesty, The Legend of Zelda always kind of disappointed me. Like, why wasn’t it about an awesome lady warrior named Zelda? Why is the game actually about this guy in a pointy hat who rescues boring ol’ Zelda? Anyway, apparently Link is an elf so he gets a place on this list. I’m not convinced he deserves it, though.








The RPG spin-off elf: Tanis Half-Elven

dragonlanceObviously my favourite Dragonlance character is Rasitlin, because he is the best, but Tanis is the main character/defacto leader of the group in Dragons of Autumn Twilight, so he gets the nod here. That said, my abiding memories of DoAT centre around Raistlin being awesome, Goldmoon being a damsel in distress, Tasslehoff being hilarious, and Tanis being kind of dull. But leader characters are often pretty dull, aren’t they? Also, in the interest of full disclosure, my abiding memory of DoAT comes from the time I played the RPG with a group of friends. I was Tasslehoff, because I’m always the short, chaotic, pain-in-the-butt character.




The comic book elf: Leetah

elfquestThe elves in Elfquest are descended from aliens, I guess? So: there are two tribes, the Wolfriders and the Sun Folk, and they intermingle and ride wolves and are telepathic or telekinetic or something. Anyway, there is lots of elf-sex, which I found very racy when I was like 12, and they ride wolves which is always awesome, and my favourite was Leetah, the leader of the Sun Folk, mostly because she had awesome hair. I mean, I was 12.







The house-elf: Kreacher

house-elfIn total fairness, JK Rowling was doing something really interesting when she introduced house-elves to the Harry Potter mythology; the way the wizarding world unthinkingly relies on their efforts is pretty appalling, and Hermione’s well-meaning response is… well, I’m not sure it’s that helpful, but it’s what makes her such a legitimately compelling character. But the house-elf plotlines tended to go in circles, and Dobby was annoying (though not as annoying as on film!) and all his Hogworts house-elf friends were poorly developed. (Remember the one with the drinking problem?)  But there was a light at the end of the house-elf tunnel: Kreacher was hilarious dolorous and he betrayed Sirius and Harry had to learn that very important coming-of-age lesson, How to Forgive, because of him. And most importantly, he wandered around talking to himself and complaining about the protagonists while in earshot of them, which is awesome. Fifty points to Kreacher.


3 comments on “Five Elves of Unquestionable Likeability”

  • Rosa McMillan says:

    No room for every teenage nerd’s favourite reformed drow and spawner of a thousand apostrophised (it’s a word) online handles?

    Drizzt Do’Urden, he of the lavender eyes, the twin scimitars and the pet panther that turned into a statue for easy carrying?

    Name another character from the Icewind Dale trilogy, I challenge you.

  • fantasywind says:

    Speaking of Elves with attitude, Feanor (or some of his sons) would be better pick for Tolkien ones hehe :). Actually I was pretty upset about the characterization of Elvenking Thranduil in movies, they completely changed him from his more nuanced book version to basically a villainous one sided jerk, shame in book he was much more sympathetic, not to mention much more reasonable and responsible leader.

Join the discussion

Your email address will not be published.